Fragment #6 – Are Our Churches Actually Christian?

Nanowrimo is not happening for me this year, but I’m trying to write everyday in November. I’ll be posting fragments of what I write here daily, edited very lightly for clarity and grammar. Here’s post #6.

If you assume that behaviors are our most reliable indicator of people’s beliefs (not what people say they believe, or think that they believe, but which values actually determine the day-to-day choices of their lives), then we should be able to empirically test whether the ecclesial communities who claim to follow Jesus actually do so in a way that is meaningfully different than the rest of the general population.

And, if you are one of those sorts who are skeptical that the most important things in life can be measured, that all the real transformation happens invisibly on the inside, then let me introduce you to a couple people who would strongly disagree with you: Jesus and Paul….And what are the fruits of the spirit, you may ask? Are they, as some church growth models suggest, things like increased budgets, more members, or more butts in the seats for Sunday worship? No, they are “love, joy, peace, forbearance, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness and self-control.” In other words, *precisely* the sort of visible, concrete habits that your neighbors and friends will notice. You want to know whether you’re actually engaged in a living relationship with God? See what’s actually coming out of your life to know whether you’re deceiving yourself or not.

In case you’re wondering, a few of these studies have been done (often by religious organizations, such as the Barna Research Group and Willow Creek Church) to evaluate the fruit of churchgoers and do you know what they’ve discovered about whether they show any evidence that would indicate a living, transformational with God?

The very simple answer is that they don’t.

In other words, church, as we commonly call it, makes no more difference in making you more like Jesus than being part of your local Kiwanis, going to a certain local McDonald’s, or occasionally visiting the gym.

No difference at all.

2 thoughts on “Fragment #6 – Are Our Churches Actually Christian?

  1. I’m surprised that “going to church” makes no diff, but it also saddens me.
    I was hoping you would say there’s a small diff, even though after the Vine
    I see the real diff between church and following Jesus.
    It saddens me that the diff is so stark, kinda like “I’ve fallen and I can’t get up”

    1. Hey Keith – I think that the Vine was a type of church so unlike the kind of “local church” described by demographers, that I’m pretty sure a lot of good churchgoers wouldn’t even have recognized the Vine as a church! (And I do have to say, for all the numerous mistakes we made, we definitely tried, with deep integrity.)

      Actually – your quote, that “the Vine ruined me for normal church” is part of what set me down this path – and I know it made it impossible for me to return to church as I knew it before (as I know it did for you!)

Leave a Reply to Keith Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *